Let’s pretend, just for a moment, that you are the greatest sled-dog racer in the world. You have entered the famed Iditarod race from Anchorage to Nome. Halfway through the race you are literally miles ahead of your closest competitor.
Then in a quiet section of the vast Alaska forests, you press the brake on your sled and your dogs come to a halt. You step off the sled and walk around to your lead dog, a brilliant animal that’s won for you many times in the past.
You pull out a Smith and Wesson .357 Magnum, aim it at the dog’s head, and pull the trigger.
Would that make any sense? No. Nor does it make any sense that Fox News just fired Tucker Carlson. Carlson has been the highest-rated personality on Fox News for years, and Fox News has been the highest-rated cable news network for years. Compared to Fox, CNN is a booger on its rear-view mirror. Some Fox News programs have been the highest-rated programs on cable TV, period.
And Tucker Carlson is their lead dog.
Understanding why this happened requires an ability to surmise from limited information, because no one at Fox or elsewhere is going to tell you what actually happened. Here’s my theory:
Rupert Murdoch, the man who built the Fox network and Fox News, is 92 years old.
Rupert Murdoch has three adult children itching to take over his business.
As the children of an extremely rich person, Murdoch’s kids grew up in a very rarefied world. Like King Charles, they were allowed to say outrageously stupid things with no one contradicting them. They are far more liberal than Rupert. Their friends are appalled, just appalled, that Fox News says all those conservative, conspiracy-theory things.
Fox knew it would lose the first defamation trial with Dominion Voting Systems. The judge in the case made two rulings last month that basically guaranteed it. He first ruled that 19 statements made by or on Fox News were false, doing the jury’s job for them. Then he ruled that Dominion had been defamed per se and didn’t need to show it had suffered monetary damages, taking another key decision out of the hands of the jury.
But rather than appeal the case after losing, Fox settled the case last week for $800 million, essentially admitting guilt and leaving it with no recourse. Who would do that?
Rupert’s kids would do that. They didn’t have to sweat for the $800 million; that’s the stockholders’ problem. And they don’t like Fox News anyway. They’d rather have a mildly-liberal network with lousy ratings that would get advertising from big nationally-known businesses. Fox has been suffering under a boycott from multinationals for years, and the Murdoch kids don’t like people like Mike “My Pillow” Lindell. He’s crass. He’s a Christian. He made his own money. He’s not one of them. Their friends would be nicer to them if Mike Lindell and Tucker Carlson were gone.
Whatever happens to Fox News now, it isn’t gonna be more conservative in the future. Expect the slide to mediocrity to begin forthwith.
Carlson’s firing makes it even clearer that the 2020 election featured huge doses of voter and election fraud. Dominion may not have been involved—even though their software and machines could have been set up to deliver false results—but somebody was.
It was hard to believe that a doddering old fool like Joe Biden could stay in his basement throughout the campaign, appear in “Town Hall” meetings where the hand-picked citizens read pre-written questions and Biden read off pre-written answers, and win an election against a popular incumbent president.
A quick comparison of the votes in 2016 and 2020 might help. At one in the morning on Election Night 2016, here’s how it looked:
Michigan: Trump leads by 33,000 votes.
Georgia: Trump leads by 350,000 votes.
Wisconsin: Trump leads by. 72,000 votes.
Pennsylvania: Trump trails by 66,000 votes.
By the morning, Trump had won all four of those states and the presidency.
Now let’s look at 2020, once again after one a.m. on Election Night:
Michigan: Trump leads by 300,000 votes.
Georgia: Trump leads by 247,000 votes.
Wisconsin: Trump leads by 108,000 votes.
Pennsylvania: Trump leads by 650,000 votes.
But by the time the counting was complete, Trump had lost all four of these states and the presidency. If Trump had been trailing at 1:37 a.m., his losing might have been acceptable, but the huge change between late at night and the next day or so truly defies credibility. Trump, and the American people, were robbed.
It shouldn’t be a big surprise that Fox News anchors and commenters were filled with disbelief, and they should have been allowed to say so. If firing Tucker Carlson was part of the Dominion settlement, we can now look forward to years of Soviet-style news reports applauding Our Glorious Leaders in the Democratic Party. If the Democrats could overcome Trump’s big leads in 2020—and then get people who bring up inconvenient facts fired from their jobs—they could make Daffy Duck our next president.
And he’d still be better than Kamala Harris.
Rene, it's now some three weeks after your blog about the “young Murdoch guns” at Fox News and their decision to oust Tucker Carlson. Now, we are beginning to engage Paul Harvey’s famous adage: “… and now you know the rest of the story.”
Your original assessment in the April 24, 2023 blog post was insightful and good, and while your main points remain immutable there is so much more to the story that is just now unfolding. And it’s rich… oh so rich! It harkens the old planning axiom: there are the intended consequences (of taking a certain action), yet there are ALWAYS the unintended consequences, too. And, my-oh-my!... the sparks and fireworks of the unintended consequences are just beginning.
To wit: it’s now the 2nd week of May 2023, and Tucker just announced that he is shifting his entire news platform to Twitter. Yes!... Tucker Carlson and Elon Musk are teaming up! Hip-Hip-Hooray!
What a magnificently unexpected foil to that unctuously arrogant and aristocratic crowd for which the young Murdoch heirs associate and suck-up. From my spot in the cheap seats, I suspect that the Tucker/Elon dynamic duo will probably leave a few stains in this crowd's BVDs. In fact, it might be even more than a few stains… I suspect it’s more like a full 5 lb potato sack of “unintended consequences” in their britches! And I am perfectly fine with such a deliciously wicked outcome. 😉
Oh, and this little tidbit: Tucker Carlson’s predecessor at Fox News, Megyn Kelly – a person who knows a lot about the inner workings at Fox News Corp (and who has the same legal representation for media contracts as Tucker) – reports that Fox News has, indeed, NOT fired Tucker and is still paying him his full salary…to do nothing. To stay on the sidelines. To be unvoiced. To be unheard. Interestingly, Tucker’s contract with Fox News runs through January 2025… ahem, just after the 2024 elections are completed. As Dana Carvey’s “Church Lady” character would skewer: “How conveeeeeenient!”
Megyn’s #1 Enemy and Antagonist at Fox News is not so much the Murdoch heirs but a Fox executive by the name of Irena Briganti, Sr Exec VP of Corporate Communications. Megyn has some very dicey, if not unpleasant things to say about her time at Fox News and how Irena was thorn in just about everyone’s side. She is quite certain that Irena is in full play here AND on full display. And apparently, the laissez-faire management style of the aristocratic Murdoch heirs leaves Briganti wide open to do her skullduggery at-will behind the scenes at Fox.
If Tucker is still receiving full salary from Fox and he’s now working with Elon Musk, Megyn feels certain that (another) Fox lawsuit is afoot, this time against Tucker Carlson for breach of contract. Yet, I get the very strong feeling that Megyn thinks it will be a lose-lose situation for the cable news network. To modify your opening analogy, Rene, it would be like taking your dog sled team and instead of shooting your lead dog you instruct him to go run around in the woods for the next two years yet telling him, “Don’t go run off too much, now!” How on earth would you make sense of such decision making in a court of law? (And Megyn would know as she is an attorney by education… just as you are, too!)
Yup, this whole saga is gonna be rich. Get the popcorn, folks. The show is about to start! 😊
Thank you for your intellectual journalism and refreshing point of view.